What’s in a name? Weinland: Columbus Short North neighborhood, park and school. But who was Weinland?

PLEASE NOTE: The blog contains quite a few pictures so give it several minutes to download. They download haphazardly.

“But who was Weinland?”, the title of this blog, is an easy find. Enter Weinland in the search field of Wikipedia on Google, scroll down to See also, and then click Weinland Park. Just who was Edgar L. Weinland? Based on the short one paragraph description provided, not even this “free online encyclopia” knows much about Edgar.

Despite having graduated from Otterbein University plus working there for 31 years, I had never heard of Edgar Lynn Weinland. Nor was I aware of a Columbus city park, neighborhood and school named Weinland. But while doing post-retirement volunteer scanning of historical material for Otterbein’s Digital Commons, I kept seeing the name. And so a search began.

Upon completing his program of study at Otterbein in 1891, Edgar Weinland attended law school at Ohio State University and was a member of its very first graduating class. Just who he was and what he accomplished over his lifetime are best described by the images that follow concluding with a biography written by his daughter. But briefly: he taught law classes at Franklin University and OSU, was later hired as Assistant Solicitor (attorney) of the City of Columbus, then promoted to Solicitor, and then became Special Council to the Attorney General of Ohio working well past retirement age into his late 80’s.

My blogging began several years ago with a focus on two separate areas: (1) local history and (2) the designs of the Columbus architectural firm Yost & Packard. While scrolling through microfilmed copies of the Westerville Public Opinion newspaper, I found an article about Frank Packard having designed a remodel of a room in Otterbein’s Towers Hall for the Philomathean Literary Society. Back then, literary societies were the norm at colleges and universities. These were the forerunner to what became fraternities and sororities. A young Packard was just beginning his career and Weinland, as Philomathean president, would have directed the project (the University let the societies fund and make their own decisions as to how to furnish their rooms). Later, Packard designed the Columbus home of Edgar and Grace Weinland. He also designed Otterbein’s Carnegie Library, the construction of which was overseen by Weinland. The association of these two men provided the perfect opportunity to combine my two interests into one and the same blog.

Why was a park named after Edgar Weinland? That was never stated in The Columbus Dispatch nor in any other research. It could be due to publicity generated by the displacement of a few disgruntled residents living in condemned housing located in what was to become the park. Due to the history uncovered, Weinland seems to have been quietly effective—civic-minded–humble…these may well be the more likely reasons.

Thank you to Stephen Grinch (Otterbein University Archivist) and William C. Hill, Jr. (great-grandson of Edgar and Grace) for their contributions to this blog.

Westerville Roots

Westerville: 63 West College Avenue. Built in 1878 by Jacob and Ella Weinland where they raised their children Edgar and Mary.
While not very visible in this postcard picture, Towers Hall on the Otterbein University campus sits at the end of West College Avenue. The Weinland home is the first house on the left.
Today. The front porch was probably removed many years ago. A painter’s nightmare.
Otterbein sophomore classmates. Photo credit: Otterbein University Archives.

Public Service Chronology

Edgar Lynn Weinland
Assistant Attorney, City of Columbus.
The Columbus Dispatch 12/1/1905.
Promoted to Attorney, City of Columbus.
Photo credit: Columbus Metropolitan Library.
The Columbus Dispatch 11/11/1912.
The teachers at Weinland Park Elementary School might find this interesting. The Columbus Dispatch 11/25/1911.
The Columbus Dispatch 4/4/1917.
The Columbus Dispatch 12/10/1924.
Awarded honorary degree of Doctor of Laws by alma mater Otterbein University.
The Columbus Dispatch 6/12 and 6/16/1936.
The Columbus Dispatch 5/4/1941.
Assistant Attorney General, State of Ohio.
The Columbus Dispatch 6/20/1942.
Photo credit: Otterbein Digital Commons.
The Columbus Dispatch 10/31/1954.
The Columbus Dispatch 9/23/1956.

Connection to Architect Frank L. Packard

Packard died unexpectedly at age 57 in 1923. This is part of his obituary that appeared in The Columbus Dispatch 10/26/1923. Like Edgar Weinland, he was civic-minded.
Photo credit: Otterbein University Archives.
The 1891 Packard-designed remodel of the Philomathean Literary Society’s room in Towers Hall at Otterbein. Stain-glassed windows with wood trim, stain-glassed entry with wood trim, decorative ceiling with wood trim. Photo credit: Otterbein University Archives.
Today. Towers Hall is listed on the National Register of Historic Places.
The Weinlands moved to Columbus in 1896. In 1903, they moved into this cottage-style house at
428 West Sixth Avenue south of the OSU campus. Designed for them by Packard.
Photo credit: Grandview Heights/Marble Cliff Historical Society.
Designed by Packard and built in 1907.
An original blueprint in the Otterbein University Archives.
Weinland was Chairman of the Building Committee. Photo credit: Otterbein University Archives.
Renamed Clippinger Hall and today houses the Office of Admission.
Listed on the National Register of Historic Places.
Edgar’s sister, Mary, who was University Librarian for twenty years. Photo credit: Otterbein University Archives.
Westerville Public Opinion 4/16/1959.
Community service by Packard and Weinland. The Columbus Dispatch 10/31/1912 and 7/29/1920.
The Columbus Dispatch 5/21/1919.

Return to Hometown Roots

The 1942 move back to Westerville, 170 West Home Street adjacent to the Otterbein campus. Still working for the Ohio Attorney General at age 72 and commuting to downtown Columbus via bus.
Photo credit: William C. Hill, Jr.
The house today.
1/26/2024
Westerville Public Opinion 12/31/1942. Edgar wrote this to his children: “When a man has been married to a fine woman like your mother for 47 years, he is not suited for bachelorhood.”
Edgar and Bertie. Photo credit: William C. Hill, Jr.
The stadium, just steps from the Weinland house on West Home Street, was dedicated 10/16/1948.
Photo credit: William C. Hill, Jr.
The Columbus Dispatch 8/17/1959.
The Columbus Dispatch 8/18/1959.
The Columbus Dispatch 8/31/1961.
Otterbein Cemetery, Westerville. The gravestones in front of the Weinland monument are Edgar’s first wife, his son, and his parents.

Permanent Recognition

Edgar would likely be pleased to see a fellow Otterbein alum, park neighbor Kristen Foster ’13, modeling this sign. 🙂 The park is located at 1280 Summit Street.
The Columbus Dispatch 11/12/1952.
The school is adjacent to the park.
Fifth and Indianola Avenues.
Weinland Park neighborhood boundaries. The park is the open rectangle between Sixth and Seventh Avenues with the footprint of the elementary school above it.

Brief biography of Edgar L. Weinland

Written in 1966 by daughter Ellen Weinland Heath for The Spirit of Otterbein, brief biographies of accomplished alumni. Photo credit: Otterbein Digital Commons.

Photo credit: Otterbein University Archives.

11/2/2024 donfoster73@gmail.com

4 Comments

  1. Sherry Riviera's avatar Sherry Riviera says:

    Very interesting!    Good reading.   Thank you.Sherry Riviera Sent from my iPad

    Like

    1. Thanks, Sherry! Appreciate your following my blogs…and I appreciate your Y&P house. Found another Delaware Packard design this past week: 68 N Sandusky, the former Delaware Gas Company building. Will be adding it to the Delaware Y&P blog. Houses a real estate firm now.

      Like

  2. janetflagler's avatar janetflagler says:

    Weinland sounds like a very remarkable guy. He received so many accolades in his lifetime. I like the house on E. College Ave. better with it’s front porch. It looks too plain now. Interesting that he always chose Frank Packard as the architect for his homes.

    Sent from my iPad

    >

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Diane Schwener's avatar Diane Schwener says:

    Edgar was my great grandfather (my grandfather was Robert Augustus). This is wonderful that you put this together. I’d love to know more about what Grace did. I have Grace and Ella’s wedding rings. How are you connected to the Weinland family? – Diane Weinland Schwener.

    Like

Leave a reply to janetflagler Cancel reply